Treat yourself
Baked fresh. Worth every bite. A little New York in every bite.
Pick your obsession.
Build a box of 6, 8, 12 or 24 cookies, or choose individual cookies. Pop & Drop pickup, local delivery and shipping.
Preorder schedule
Order before Thursday at 8 PM ET for Saturday pickup or Tuesday shipping. At or after the cutoff, your order moves to the following week. No exceptions. Carrier transit time is additional.
Sometimes, you need the treat.
A little naughty. A lot delicious. Premium cookies for your everyday wins, well-earned breaks, and just-because moments.
Before you give in.
A few things to know before your next obsession.
What makes Auntie Penny cookies worth giving in to?
Handmade NYC-style cookies, from our chewy chocolate-chip Classic to rich stuffed flavors. Think Belgian chocolate, creamy fillings and generous finishes, with flavors made using European butter and Madagascar vanilla. A little New York in every bite.
Can I choose the cookies in my box?
Yes. Build a box of 6, 8, 12 or 24 cookies with your favorites from the current menu. You can also order individual cookies. Any minimum for your chosen fulfillment method is shown during ordering.
When do preorders close?
Preorders close Thursday at 8 PM Eastern. Order before the cutoff for the upcoming Saturday pickup or Tuesday shipping cycle. Orders placed at or after the cutoff skip that upcoming cycle and move to the following week’s Saturday pickup or Tuesday shipping.
Do you ship cookies?
Yes, to eligible destinations. Available services and shipping costs are shown during checkout. Tuesday is our shipping day; carrier transit time is additional, and arrival depends on your destination and selected service. Review our shipping, delivery and pickup information when planning your treat.
Can Auntie Penny cater my event?
Absolutely. Bring a little New York indulgence to your celebration, office gathering or special occasion. Tell us about your event through our catering inquiry form, and we’ll discuss the cookies, quantities and availability with you.
What if I have a food allergy?
Ingredients vary by flavor. Our cookies are made in a kitchen that works with dairy, eggs, soy, wheat, peanuts and tree nuts, and our bakery is not free of allergens. Read the cookie details and contact us before ordering if you have a food allergy.