top of page

FRESH

HANDMADE

MADE 4 U

MADE 4 FAMILIES

New York bridge artwork in Auntie Penny pink and cyan

Penny Points.

Give yourself a delicious reason to give in. Five rewards. Every one worth the wait.

  1. 01

    Join the crew

    • Make it official. Create your account, sign in when you order, and let every cookie craving bring your next reward closer. Redeem through My Rewards; points never expire.

  2. 02

    Earn points

    • Sign up to the site

      Get 25 points

    • Treat yourself to cookies

      Get 10 points for every $1 spent

  3. 03

    Give in. Get rewarded.

    • Silver — Your First Temptation

      2,000 Points = $10 off a specific category

    • Gold — Give In

      2,400 Points = $12 off orders over $12

    • Platinum — The Indulgence Box

      15,000 Points = 100% off a specific category

    • Iridium — An Occasion Worth Giving In To

      30,000 Points = 100% off a specific category

    • Rhodium — The Baker’s Reserve

      60,000 Points = 100% off a specific category

bottom of page