Good food has always been Auntie Penny’s way of saying, “You’re family.”
Handmade New York-style cookies. Worth the anticipation.
Auntie Penny is a Brooklyn-based cookie brand making handmade New York-style cookies with generous proportions and rich stuffed flavors. Looking for NYC cookies with a little more character? Explore the dough, filling and finish of each flavor, then build a box around your cravings. Our belief is simple: the pleasure should live up to the anticipation. Your craving deserves a cookie worth choosing.
Our Story
The name “Penny” comes from her childhood nickname. As a toddler, she preferred her grandmother’s love of cooking over cartoons. Her grandmother taught her that food is the ultimate way to show love.
After moving to America and rediscovering her passion during the pandemic, Penny decided to turn her lifelong hobby into a mission.
Why the name Auntie Penny? Because we want every customer to feel like family, bringing us together through cookies.
What makes a premium cookie worth choosing?
There’s something special about knowing the cookies in your box were made for you. At Auntie Penny, that’s the heart of our pre-order approach: we handcraft your cookies for your order, in the flavors you chose and with the care we would give to someone in our own family.
That care starts with what goes into the cookie—and what waits inside. We took our time choosing Callebaut Belgian chocolate, Madagascar vanilla, rich European-style butter, premium flour, organic eggs and USDA-certified organic whole milk. Milk, dark or white, our chocolate is Belgian, chosen to complement the dough, filling and finish of each recipe.
When a recipe calls for brown butter, we make it ourselves from European-style butter, carefully managing the heat and time to develop its rich, nutty depth. And handmade means hands-on: each cookie is shaped and finished by hand, and our stuffed varieties are filled by hand, too. Every swirl, filling and finishing touch is part of making the cookies you’ve been looking forward to.
The care continues beyond the oven. Your cookies are carefully packed and sealed in protective Mylar bags to help preserve their freshness on their way to you—whether your order is shipped, locally delivered or picked up.
We put our pride and joy into making your cookies because we want you to feel like family from the moment you open the box. You chose something special for yourself or someone you love. We take that personally, in the sweetest way.
Handcrafted for you. Worth the anticipation.
What is inside Brookie Dream?
Brookie Dream starts with our premium blonde dough, made with USDA-certified organic whole milk and marbled by hand with pieces of our handmade brownies and Belgian milk chocolate chips. Inside, more handmade brownie meets caramel. On top, brownie pieces, Belgian milk and white chocolate, and a scattering of Oreo cookie-shell crumbs bring the layers together. We crush those shells ourselves, then shape, fill and finish each cookie by hand. A little brownie, a little cookie—and plenty to look forward to.
What are Auntie Penny’s New York-style cookies like?
Generous proportions, rich dough and flavors worth slowing down for. Auntie Penny makes handmade NYC-style cookies with combinations of mix-ins, fillings and finishes that vary by recipe. Explore each flavor’s description and Cookie details to choose the texture and center that suit your craving.
How do I choose the best New York cookies for my taste?
Start with the flavor you keep thinking about: deep chocolate, buttery caramel or bright fruit flavors. Read each cookie’s flavor notes and allergen information, then choose the available flavors for a box of 6, 8, 12 or 24. The best choice for your box is the one you cannot wait to open.
Bring home a little Brooklyn. Choose a box of 6, 8, 12 or 24 handmade NYC-style cookies. Go for the chewy chocolate-chip Classic, the Biscoff center of Butter Bliss, or a mix for the people waiting back home.
For Saturday Pop & Drop pickup, order before Thursday at 8 p.m. Eastern. Choose a listed location and check its fixed Saturday pickup window against your travel plans. Orders placed at or after the cutoff move to the following week. You can also ship four or more cookies to an eligible U.S. address. Shipping orders go out Tuesday, and carrier transit time is additional. Build your box · Check shipping
Permission granted. Treat yourself.
For the little wins, the long days and the just-because moments. A little naughty. A lot delicious. You don’t have to earn a moment of joy.