Handmade Heavenly
Cookie Boxes
Customize Your
Cookie Box
Step 1
Chose Your Cookie
Step 2
Chose Your Combo
Step 3
Indulge
About Us
At Auntie Penny, we don’t believe in shelf life — everything’s baked fresh to order, just for you. Every cookie, roll, and babka starts from scratch the same day you order it. No shortcuts. No thawed dough. No “good enough.”
It all started in our home kitchen — a little comfort project that turned into something bigger. Friends and neighbors couldn’t stop talking about “those cookies,” “these rolls,” and “that babka,” so we thought: why not share it with more people who need that same taste of home?
Now, Auntie Penny is for every student pulling late nights, every friend group splitting a box during finals week, and everyone who just wants something warm, gooey, and real. Because sometimes, the best kind of comfort isn’t delivered by text — it comes in a box, straight from the oven.
Real comfort food — baked fresh for every pre-order, just for you.
Gotta Eat 'Em All
Our Sweet Clients
"These cookies are absolute perfection! The chocolate chips are generous and the cookies are soft and chewy.”
Ingrid B.
“Best chocolate chip cookies I've ever had, hands down."
Lilly F.
"The cookie box arrived beautifully packaged and the cookies were fresh and delicious”
Dean X.
"The chocolate chip cookies are the best I've ever tasted! The box arrived quickly and the cookies were fantastic”
Dean X.
